| Platinum | Calico County Restaurant |
| Gold | Patrick's Butcher Boy Burgers |
| Silver | George's Restaurant |
| Bronze | Dave's Iron Skillet |
| Top Pick | Boh Flavors |
| Top Pick | Buffalo Burger |
| Top Pick | Lewis Family Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Sonic Drive-In |
| Top Pick | The Mothership Ufo Burgers |
| Top Pick | Yellow Umbrella |