| Platinum | El Olvido |
| Gold | El Mariachi Mexican Grill |
| Silver | George's Restaurant |
| Bronze | Las Americas Too |
| Top Pick | AJ's Oyster House |
| Top Pick | Bruce Terri Catering |
| Top Pick | Miss Anna's |
| Top Pick | Rub M Tender |
| Top Pick | The Mothership Ufo Burgers |
| Top Pick | Walk-On's Sports Bistreaux - Ft. Smith |