| Platinum | Calico County Restaurant |
| Gold | Lily's Sandwich Shop |
| Silver | Schlotzsky's |
| Bronze | Cheddar's Scratch Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Buffalo Burger |
| Top Pick | Geno's Pizza |
| Top Pick | John's Hoagies |
| Top Pick | Panera Bread |
| Top Pick | Real Food Co |
| Top Pick | River City Bistro |