| Platinum | Steffey's Pizza |
| Gold | Hidaway Pizza |
| Silver | Gusano's Chicago-Style Pizzeria |
| Bronze | Vinnie's Pies |
| Top Pick | Cavanaugh Pizza |
| Top Pick | Domino's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Geno's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Godfather's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Joe's Pizza and Pasta Italian Grill |
| Top Pick | Papa's Pub & Pizzeria |