| Platinum | El Lorito Mexican Restaurant |
| Gold | El Olvido |
| Silver | El Mariachi Mexican Grill |
| Bronze | El Trio |
| Top Pick | El Palenque |
| Top Pick | El Toro Grill & Cantina |
| Top Pick | El Zarape Mexican Grill |
| Top Pick | Joe's Grill & Cantina |
| Top Pick | La Huerta Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Las Americas Too |