| Platinum | Calico County Restaurant |
| Gold | George's Restaurant |
| Silver | Amazing Graze |
| Bronze | Neumeier's Rib Room |
| Top Pick | Beef 'O' Bradys |
| Top Pick | Bruce Terri Catering |
| Top Pick | Ed Walker's Drive-In & Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Geno's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Mel's Catering |
| Top Pick | River City Bistro |